Hasnt this thread moved away from vibrating collars! 
That's true, but I love hearing about other oldies, as Ben is my first I just want to make sure I am doing it right, it's so lovely hearing about Millie and the others 
Yes, its great comparing notes... Millie is my first, too! I had thought I was pushing Millie too much by occasionally insisting that we stay out for an hour, even at a slow pace... Pleased to see that Ben is managing this regularly.
Had to smile to myself today... We used the lead on the walk to give Millie confidence!
Because we were walking directly into sunlight, she kept turning away from the brightness and then losing me. As soon as we were in shade she was happy offlead, as she was when on loose sunlit lead... 😄
