I have not thought of the collar, basically because I always thought they were cruel things for some reason! I think it was because I used a muzzle with Zara my lurcher as she was very destructive, and it made her worse! At that point though, I didn't know SA existed - it was a good few years ago now, and one of the reasons that I have not had a dog since! Then I got Sophie and the same thing started - although she is not in the slightest destructive - just upsetting to listen to.
Tried covering the crate with Sophie, didn't help as she got herself so worked up that she was puffing and panting like mad and I was scared that even though the front of the crate was open, she was going to overheat.
I can't leave Beau out of the crate at the moment, he is still in the puppy stage & and is a wee devil, and he is not totally house trained yet (yes, I know he is 8mths, but he is learning fast!)
The thing about the doggy day care is that it is not that as such, it is merely a day kennels. I would prefer if someone would spend some time with them, rather than just the exercise walk that they get. I think putting them in there might make their barking worse? Would they understand that when they are in the house they are not allowed to bark, when no-one chastises them for it in the kennels?
I have always left the tv or radio on for Sophie - but as I said before, once the panic kicks in for her a jumbo jet could land in the living room and she would not veer off her "where is Mum" course - she would stay in panic mode until I returned.
I am so confused as I feel that I have tried everything, but as far as the separation training goes - I can't seem to get past a certain stage, then the barking starts again! And I do it every day!