oh yes, I growled back haha, shes currently sat next to me after her time out in the kitchen, chewing on my hoodie, I keep replacing it with the toys, perserverance I think, Shes lovely when she's asleep haha, and the OH tells her off and she listens its really annoying tbh, especially when I'm trying to train her and she does it almost instantly with him! im gonna try and be more calm when shes done something bad, and keep up with the time outs and replacing my hand with her toys, I'll be glad when I can walk her and get her tired out! haha taking her to puppy classes too, see if she can learn some manners lol x