I'm still waiting for Alfie's Chow Bella bowl that I ordered for his birthday in September to arrive. It was ordered too late to arrive in time for his birthday, so don't think he'll be any the wiser if I just keep it for his Christmas
Alfie usually gets a new toy and I usually wrap up a pig's ear form his normal supply and any other treats that are 'in house'. I struggled with finding something for his birthday (posted for suggestions here) as he looks after his toys so well and he does revisit the ones at the bottom of his toy basket. I have looked at the Nina Ottoson puzzles, but am not convinced about them being a lasting challenge i.e. longer than a few mins, but maybe some COL's can convince me otherwise! This treat toy that Alfie got from PAH was a great buy - he's very slick at flicking it end to end with his paws but it still takes a good 5 mins to empty it.
http://www.petsathome.com/shop/chuckle-dog-treat-dog-toy-by-busy-buddy-32970 It looks slightly changed from the one Alfie has but still well worth a go.