CockersOnline Forum

Cocker Specific Discussion => Puppies => Topic started by: plangton on June 09, 2016, 10:56:14 PM

Title: boy or girl.
Post by: plangton on June 09, 2016, 10:56:14 PM
Hi all hope you can help.
I'm in talks with a few breeders about my first dog, and cant decide if I should get a boy or a girl.
Would anyone be able to give me some advice, possibly about the differences on the sexes.
The most important thing for me is the overall health and temperament of the dog. I would like however to train he/she to be a pat dog for the elderly.

Thanks all.
Title: Re: boy or girl.
Post by: bizzylizzy on June 10, 2016, 06:26:30 AM
Hi! To be honest, I think it comes down to the individual personality of the dog rather than the sex. I have to admit to only ever having had males but I think that's rather down to force of habit,rather than anything else. With females, you have to consider that they'll be in season every now and again so, unless you have them spayed, you need to vigilent for any admirers. Little boys, on the other hand, need to "mark" things, so walks are interrupted every so often for a quick sniff and cock of the leg! Some of the characteristics are indeed inborn, so it's worth looking for a serious registered breeder  who places value on temperament rather than striving just for the perfect looking dog. Also check that they're being well socialized by the breeder, - not reared in cages with no human contact, the first few weeks are vital to development. Good luck - keep us posted!
Title: Re: boy or girl.
Post by: cindere528 on June 10, 2016, 07:53:20 AM
In my experience, girls are much more biddable. They seem to want to please you more than the boys do. I know people with male dogs who are much more well behaved than my girls, but I think a lot more work has to go into getting boys obedient.

The only down side is that spaying a bitch is a much bigger operation than castrating a dog, if you don't have them neutered, you are building up problems for the future, either unwanted litters, or health problems.

I would say find a breeder who you trust, ask lots of questions, ask to view their animals and be prepared to wait for the right dog or bitch to become available. The best breeders have sold their litters before they are even born.

Alternatively, have a look at all the rescue dogs, having a rescue is very rewarding, and has the bonus that often, they are already housetrained and trained to walk on a lead. They also have the advantage that in most cases, you can start taking them out straight away rather than having to wait until a pup has had injections.
Title: Re: boy or girl.
Post by: Jane S on June 10, 2016, 08:22:53 AM
It's funny how our experiences can differ so much which is why there will always be a range of opinions on threads like this - I personally have never found our girls more biddable than our boys & sometimes I think new owners get told this and then are surprised when their girl turns out not to be the easily trained angel they were told they would be :005: Some of our girls have been strong willed and some of our boys have been very placid and easily trained (and vice versa), it really does depend on individual personalities I think.
Title: Re: boy or girl.
Post by: Markr64 on June 10, 2016, 09:15:34 AM
I have to agree with that it is down to the individual personality of the pup rather than the sex. Look for a pup that is not overly shy and wants to join in. Nothing wrong with the shy pups as they will also grow into a super dog with the right encouragement. Don't be guided by sex alone as the dog has to be comfortable with your situation, like do you have a family? Will there be someone always there with the animal? So many things shape the puppy from day one of ownership, so lots of research and read this forum including lots of the old threads as many are very useful and will help you choose what will be best for you.

I have had both dogs and bitches in the past of various breeds and each one has been a delight to have because we chose carefully when looking at the litter. Look at a number of breeders and don't let them choose for you but ask them lots of questions and watch the litter for as long as you are able to see if one catches your eye more than others.
Title: Re: boy or girl.
Post by: Mudmagnets on June 10, 2016, 09:37:38 AM
Have to agree it is the individual dog and not really the sex that will define whether or not it's more biddable. Having had boys and girls, I would say go more with how it is going to fit into your lifestyle.

Bitches of course will have seasons, do you want the inconvenience of this maybe twice a year, neutering is a lot more expensive and detailed for bitches than castration, I'm not saying this should definitely make your mind up one way or the other, but just something to think of for when they are past the puppy stage.
Title: Re: boy or girl.
Post by: rubybella on June 10, 2016, 11:33:31 AM
It is individual preference. I knew before I got my dogs that I only wanted girls and having had girls I wouldn't change my mind. Personally I find male dogs scenting every few minutes quite annoying, as I do other male activities like humping!!
Title: Re: boy or girl.
Post by: Ben's mum on June 10, 2016, 12:25:18 PM
It is individual preference. I knew before I got my dogs that I only wanted girls and having had girls I wouldn't change my mind. Personally I find male dogs scenting every few minutes quite annoying, as I do other male activities like humping.

You sound like me  :005: :005: My parents only ever had girls and my mum was of the opinion that boys were not quite 'nice', which was an opinion I inherited and I was very clear with OH that I would only ever consider girls.  Somehow though we ended up with two boys as they sort of chose us and my ideas went out the window when they grabbed my heart  :luv:
Title: Re: boy or girl.
Post by: tenaille on June 10, 2016, 02:51:57 PM
yes, have to agree with all these comments, I really believe what you get is down to luck not the sex. We always had boys because we found them to be more affectionate than the girls - not everyones experience I know.  Similarly with marking and humping, these are not just male traits, the girls can be just the same. In the end its really personal preference and luck, anyway you'll love it just the same whichever you get.
Title: Re: boy or girl.
Post by: plangton on June 10, 2016, 03:40:44 PM
Thank you for all your detailed comments, I am in communication with two breeders at the moment. One has only one female and the other had moth male and female. I eventually would like to train it to be a pay dog. From reading the comments, both would be good, but just depends on the individual dog. I will be having the dog done at the appropriate time, could that make a difference in temperament?.
 the bitch for one of the litters is a PRA carrier, but the farther is clear and also fn and glaucoma. And the other litter, both parents are clear of all the above, plus the farther has a low hip score.
Title: Re: boy or girl.
Post by: linda c on June 10, 2016, 04:16:54 PM
As already said it's a matter of personal choice. I've had males and females and they were all different, some easy to train others harder. Neutering sometimes affects the temperament but not always, and I would put health and temperament first every time. The more tests where both parents are clear the better. Good luck on your choice I'm sure you'll make the right one 😃
Title: Re: boy or girl.
Post by: MIN on June 10, 2016, 04:56:34 PM
I have always thought bitches are just that little bit keener.
 But in the end , the puppy will choose you. So just go and put your future way of life in the hands of whom the great DOG above  has sent for you  :luv:
Title: Re: boy or girl.
Post by: rubybella on June 10, 2016, 06:55:24 PM
Neutering made no difference to the temperament of my girls. Neither of my girls scent or hump either. If you choose a female you will have to contend with at least one season, but in my experience it really isn't that much of a big deal. In terms of neutering ops, having a female spayed is a bigger op than castration. Males are more likely to be tormented and distracted by in season females, this can cause problems when owners walk their in season females in public places!!!

If you are really not bothered either way, I would go for the litter with both a male and female and just see which one you are more taken by.
Title: Re: boy or girl.
Post by: PennyB on June 20, 2016, 06:00:20 PM
It's funny how our experiences can differ so much which is why there will always be a range of opinions on threads like this - I personally have never found our girls more biddable than our boys & sometimes I think new owners get told this and then are surprised when their girl turns out not to be the easily trained angel they were told they would be :005: Some of our girls have been strong willed and some of our boys have been very placid and easily trained (and vice versa), it really does depend on individual personalities I think.

Yep as all my boys have tended to be biddable and the girls more independent and strong willed - think in their case its just the way they are and the pups I chose, but have had bitches (fosters) in the house who are biddable and vice versa
Title: Re: boy or girl.
Post by: daw on June 20, 2016, 06:06:11 PM
I've found boys to be keener to please! Also I could never face the spay trauma again...so much easier for the owner.
Title: Re: boy or girl.
Post by: Penelope on June 21, 2016, 08:52:12 AM
I had only ever had bitches and was really quite "anti" dogs after my brother's dogs were the kind who peed on everyone and everything!  Then Dexter came into my life.  :luv:  Followed a couple of years later by Alfie  :luv:
Now, I am a convert and would only ever have boys!
In my experience, although I love my beautiful Suki, the boys are somehow different.  They are extremely loving and I don't know if it is coincidence but both of them are extremely good (when required - although they can both be  >:D) I feel as if they are that way because they want to be whereas Suki has an ulterior motive (usually food related  :005:)
Definitely boys all the way here !!!

Title: Re: boy or girl.
Post by: Blueberry on June 21, 2016, 09:00:06 AM
My previous pup, 30 years ago, was a bitch and attached very strongly to my ex husband, and although she was always affectionate towards me, she would have gladly died in the effort to please him. 
My present pup is a dog and has attached very strongly to me, is only mildly interested in my husband and doesn't make much effort to engage with him.  Although, to be fair, he really is not a dog person, and despite best efforts probably gives off some 'stay away from me' vibes.
Maybe the gender of the owner has a bearing?  I don't know.
Title: Re: boy or girl.
Post by: Murphys Law on June 21, 2016, 09:55:24 AM
We have a boy and a girl. Millie is my first bitch and very different to Murphy. She is very needy, wants attention all 6 he time but also VERY sensitive. I can't raise my voice to her as she runs up to her crate in our bedroom.

Murphy, on the other hand, is the exact opposite. A bit of a thug (in a nice sense) and much more independent.