Charlie liked the wainwright but quickly went off it. He's unbelievably fussy (although getting much better). He likes the applaws pouches (p@h) sell them, he likes the applaws kibble, the only kibble he'll eat. But raw worked for us (I started giving him one meal normal, one meal raw, but I tired all the flavors that p@h sell to get an idea of what he liked, beef was his favorite. 18 months later, he's still enjoying his raw, but he's ENJOYING it, that's something I never thought I'd say. I found the variety of raw flavors works for us.