ok , had to reply , i have a 17 week old working cocker called Benson , and he is my 1st ever dog , weve now had him for 9 weeks and i have to say he is Fantastic , he has been house trained since he was 9 weeks old , has never cried or fussed over night , although he was crated for the first 6 weeks , he now sleeps in the kitchen , and if we do go out occasionally without him he has the run of the house , but goes to sleep if were not here , im a really proud mum , and i couldnt have asked for more , thinking of getting another in the future