Author Topic: here go's  (Read 7766 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Offline supaspaniel

  • Site Member
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 1497
  • Gender: Female
Re: here go's
« Reply #15 on: March 05, 2007, 08:11:21 AM »
. If everyone stopped breeding for a year we would nearly clear all the dogs in rescue. 

I think thats just wishful thinking...not everone wants to take on a rescue as a lot of them have issues...and I would be happy to offer a home to a rescue, but wouldn't be considered because all of our dogs are intact and various other reasons and I know of people who have been refused rescue dogs just because they will be outside in a run for part of the day..etc...

Are you just going to rescue Weims from now? I may have misread but i think i have read that you may be breeding. Apologies in advance if I'm wrong ;)

The point that most of the breeders on COL make are the health issues and it is an important issue when considering breeding from your dogs.I bought my first three dogs from a 'reputable breeder' who has been breeding for over 30 years, whom I trusted implicitly...I'm not going into it, but it turns out they were not to be trusted at all. And as a result my beautiful young dog Harmy had his life cut horribly short which has left me in pieces and my family.That breeder unfortunately refused to take responsibility for breeding a dog with FN. I think this is the point that MOST are trying to make. I took a risk buying Aidee from someone who was starting out(they had had certain health tests, but not FN) , but that was a risk I had to take for personal reasons and the gamble has paid off so far, but I wouldn't recommend anyone just getting a cocker for the first time to do that.

I dont think that people who do well in the show ring should have monopoly over breeding, but anyone just breeding cos they want to have a little pup from their pet really must research everything before going ahead and understand the responsibility. IT IS A HUGE RESPONSIBILITY
The fact that dogs end up in rescue is not necessarily the breeders fault...that also lies with unsuitable owners not researching the breed :-\
 
Zen Dog...he knows not where he is going, for the ocean will decide. Its not the destination....its the glory of the ride.

Offline Helen

  • Moderator
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 20025
  • Gender: Female
    • helen noakes jewellery
Re: here go's
« Reply #16 on: March 05, 2007, 08:17:23 AM »
its a little narrow to have to insist that the only reputable breeders are those that show, thats simply not true because the cocker has sadly lost its roots and the breed has split, the working cocker is bred based on its working ability first and foremost beauty comes second although there are some breeders from both sides of the coin that are trying to do both or at least meet in the middle -

I agree Tasha - which is why I referred to show strains in my post  ;) But surely in the case of working dogs, they should be "proven" either in trials or the field? At the moment, the breeding of working cockers is a growth area, purely because they have a lower maintaintance coat, and they can still be advertised as "cute" cocker spaniels - which can lead to disappointment on the part of the new owners, as past posts have shown :(

I know that in some other countries, gundogs have to be proven in both the showing and the field to become a champion; but from a purely selfish perspective, I don't like the idea  ph34r I was particularly looking for a dog as a pet which did not have a high working drive; and if reputably bred pedigrees were selected for their working ability, then there would be far fewer suitable homes able to meet their needs  :-\


so really rachel you are perpetuating the show/worker split as you don't want a gundog with gundog tendencies....well that's how your post reads to me.  I for one like the idea of a working test (it doesn't mean the dog has to work constantly - i questioned Katina on this on another post) as part of the requirements for showing.  After all this was what the gundog was bred originally to do.  This is not an attempt to belittle any of the show owners here - i know the amount of hard work and dedication you put into showing your dogs and really admire your work.

With working cockers I don't consider a swathe of FT CH's as a requirement for a good working cocker nowadays - this would narrow the gene pool further and I don't feel seeing the same sire time and time again on a pedigree is a particularly good thing.   Field trials don't interest me at all, and only a small proportion of Working cocker owners do the trials.  There are many other factors which i do consider and are listed in other posts.

As you know I am not one of the *disappointed* working cocker owners, a worker was my considered choice - i know some owners are and they are being bred as indiscrimanently as are show cockers.  I wonder if we see more in rescue now because more is known about workers and recognising them - in the past as you know they were referred to as spaniel crosses.

Breeding to 'standard' has not always benefitted a breed - I'm not talking about English Cocker Spaniels here.... I'm referring to Bull breeds and Alsations particularly, the changes and resulting problems are well documented.

helen & jarvis x


Offline sarah25

  • Site Member
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 4422
  • Gender: Female
  • Charbonnel Love'N'It At Oramiss
    • Oramiss Cocker Spaniels
Re: here go's
« Reply #17 on: March 05, 2007, 08:21:42 AM »
I agree with everything Jane has said.
There's alot of people out there who just wants to have a puppy from there bitch because shes 'pretty' alot of people dont do there homework either on another fourm people was saying that people who breed only do it for the money which is not the case!

Offline Jane S

  • Administrator
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 13205
  • Gender: Female
Re: here go's
« Reply #18 on: March 05, 2007, 09:08:30 AM »
At the end of the day people show because its a hobby and an interest, you can only show the same dog for so many years and yes there is an element of breeding to attain a certain look to 'win' but that doesn't necessarily mean its for the benefit of the breed otherwise we wouldn't have a split in it.  What it does mean is that they have read the standard and are trying to breed to achieve that but in the process are breeding far too many dogs... those benefit the pet market requirements.

If you study the BRS Tasha, you'll find that show breeders are only responsible for a small percentage of puppies registered each quarter and this percentage has gone down in the years since we started our involvement in Cockers. It is not show breeders who are breeding far too many dogs but the enormous number of commercial & backyard breeders who are ever increasing (and are now also turning their attentions to the Working Cocker). I can't personally see the difference between a good show breeder and a good Working Cocker breeder in so far as each have an aim in their breeding program but not every puppy will fulful that aim & so each type of breeder will have "surplus" puppies which go to hopefully carefully vetted pet homes. This type of breeding does not cause a problem if done responsibly with the health & welfare of the breed in mind but the key word is "responsibly", something I'm sure we can all agree on ;)
Jane

Offline claireandmartin

  • Site Member
  • Sr. Member
  • ****
  • Posts: 259
  • Gender: Female
  • xxx zak xxx
Re: here go's
« Reply #19 on: March 05, 2007, 12:20:32 PM »
thanx for yor comments but i still got one querey lol ph34r how come its ok for people to breed for show , on most of the breeders websites it does say they don't have many litters only when they are wanting to keep a pup for show..
so what about the pups they don't want ?
ZAK MY GEORGEOUS GOLDEN BOY

Offline CarolineL

  • Site Member
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 2291
  • Gender: Female
Re: here go's
« Reply #20 on: March 05, 2007, 12:51:29 PM »
thanx for yor comments but i still got one querey lol ph34r how come its ok for people to breed for show , on most of the breeders websites it does say they don't have many litters only when they are wanting to keep a pup for show..
so what about the pups they don't want ?

If a breeder has bred a litter of puppies in the hope that one of them will be good to show - the remaining puppies in the litter are the ones that are sold on to people like you and me and become family pets.
Caroline, Hurley the cocker, Jasper Cat and Little Mo xxxxx

"My name's not Hurley, it's Hugo Reyes. Hurley's just a nickname I have. Why?.... I'm not telling..."

Offline Kim

  • Site Member
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 1272
    • Molkara Cocker Spaniels
Re: here go's
« Reply #21 on: March 05, 2007, 12:53:19 PM »
thanx for yor comments but i still got one querey lol ph34r how come its ok for people to breed for show , on most of the breeders websites it does say they don't have many litters only when they are wanting to keep a pup for show..
so what about the pups they don't want ?

If a breeder has bred a litter of puppies in the hope that one of them will be good to show - the remaining puppies in the litter are the ones that are sold on to people like you and me and become family pets.

Yes, hopefully healthy, happy, sound pets, which actually look like the breed they are supposed to be.
www.Molkara.co.uk

Save the earth; it's the only planet with chocolate.

Offline silkstocking

  • Site Member
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 3399
  • Gender: Female
Re: here go's
« Reply #22 on: March 05, 2007, 12:57:45 PM »
thanx for yor comments but i still got one querey lol ph34r how come its ok for people to breed for show , on most of the breeders websites it does say they don't have many litters only when they are wanting to keep a pup for show..
so what about the pups they don't want ?

Then REPUTABLE breeders find suitable pet or show homes for the rest of the litters to go to ;) And I mean SUITABLE! It isn't unheard for reputable breeders to turn people down when the want a puppy from their litter, I know my own breeder/friend, gives people their marching orders lol if she doesn't deem the suitable homes. Unlike puppy farmsers who will give a puppy to anyone no questions asked >:( >:(

Personally I would not be inclined to buy a puppy from anyone but a person who shows their dogs ( I'm talking with regard to show cockers because that is where my basic knowledge lies!). That is not to say that ALL people who show their dogs take on board everything that we bring up when people discuss  breeding here, however from my limited knowledge I would say on the whole they do ;)

 
there are many posts from people on here who are thinking of breeding their bitches and might i add wanting to do it the right way but when ever i read a post about it  it seems like they always get a negative responce, why is this surley if they have had all the relevent tests done and have found a suitable stud dog why not...

 It's COL's job to make sure that everyone thinking about breeding goes about it the right way and for the right reasons. It's too important an issue not to be treated seriously which is why replies may seem negative but they're made with the interests of the breed we all love at heart. I'm sure everyone who gives advice on these kind of threads gets very disheartened by the "I'll do what I want" attitude of some would-be breeders but every now and again, someone does listen (like Lucy A :D) which means our efforts weren't wasted ;)


Exactly!! ;) ;)

Offline Cob-Web

  • Inactive
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 10276
  • Gender: Female
  • To err is human, to forgive, canine
    • Walking on Wight Blog
Re: here go's
« Reply #23 on: March 05, 2007, 01:14:41 PM »
That is not to say that ALL people who show their dogs take on board everything that we bring up when people discuss  breeding here, however from my limited knowledge I would say on the whole they do ;)

Sadly, I'm not so sure that being active in the show world is an indication of reputability :( Many of the show breeders (some doing very well) that I have come across do not carry out heath screening/testing :(
Enrich your life with an Oldie!
Oldies Club


Offline silkstocking

  • Site Member
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 3399
  • Gender: Female
Re: here go's
« Reply #24 on: March 05, 2007, 01:17:00 PM »
That is not to say that ALL people who show their dogs take on board everything that we bring up when people discuss  breeding here, however from my limited knowledge I would say on the whole they do ;)

Sadly, I'm not so sure that being active in the show world is an indication of reputability :( Many of the show breeders (some doing very well) that I have come across do not carry out heath screening/testing :(

That is why I said not ALL ;) ::)

Offline Tasha

  • Site Member
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 1564
Re: here go's
« Reply #25 on: March 05, 2007, 03:53:58 PM »
I'm not going to get into the debate about whether or not show or working breeders are proliforating the BRS I think it would just go round in a circle and get us no where especially as these volumes fluctuate and both are as bad as each other.  Both also have the disadvantage that pet breeders are breeding from them so its a little difficult to tell just from the pedigree who is truely working their dogs and who is a pet breeder, think the same can be said of the show world.

Field trialling although great for a few individuals is not where most of the working dogs earn their stripes - thats done in the field, you'll find that most owners of good bitches have a waiting list for their puppies from people that have seen or had their bitch recommended because she is a good solid worker and will hopefully pass that onto her puppies.  I could have choosen a pup from a litter that had FT CH in nearly every line but I choose a bitch from a litter of pups where 1) I had pick of litter 2) I had seen the dogs both sire and dam working for 2 seasons and I was happy with their performance.  Both are keen little hunters and nice solid working dogs from good lines and I have to say I am very happy with my Ayla and looking forward to her joining me in the field :D

With reference to my personal breeding I come from a family that have a line of great danes and have done for decades so I have always been around good breeding ethics.  My grandmother breeds one litter every 7 years to replace her dogs and she has always had a waiting list (danes rarely live above 8 :( ) in majority from previous owners, we have always taken back our own progeny thankfully thats been rare.   As a family we have rescued more dogs than we have bred and that has always been encouraged.  At the moment I have three rescues an English Springer Spaniel and two Great Danes one of whom is deaf both of whom are Merles, the springer was a customs and excise reject bred on working lines that has Collie Eye.  I am also extremely active in two rescue services and provide a dog check and home check service regularly. I usually take on the dogs that no one wants because of high vet costs my last weimaraner rescue came to me to die and lasted with good care three years despite having cushings, arthritus, spondilious and liver and kidney problems.  I am sure you will agree that I do my part where I can.

With regard to my weimaraner bitch she is worked (something of a rarity these days for my main breed) and is a good solid dog from a great show lines and I personally need a dog back to replace her when she retires, it takes several years to train a dog for the purposes that I need them for and I have a waiting list for puppies.  She is in season at the moment and now would be the ideal time to breed her but as I am still not happy with the stud options and still looking into a pup from an alternative source I am keeping my options open :D  I have traced the dogs from both stud and my own back to the first dogs in germany to be shown (1889).  This includes health problems where possible over the last 10 generations.

What I can assure is that any dog that I breed will be returned to me and I will either rehome it or retain it, restrictions will be placed on the pups with a requirement to have health checks done at my expense.  I have the facilities to keep up to ten dogs at a time and a large family who have always been happy to hold and home dogs for me if needed :D

My weimaraner is a little special she is a trained guide/assistance dog and has been used as one since she was a pup, she represents her breed every year at events like discover dogs has a fabulous temperment, attends crufts through the gamekeepers classes although she has several nice red rosettes from other shows  :D  She has good hips (A2, 4/4, german Normal), coat tested whch is new in the uk and has eye tested clear (weims are not usually tested).  Breeding from her is certainly not something that I am taking lightly, there will be no financial gain only a loss and I doubt that the majority of breeders have gone to the lengths that I have before considering a litter....



Offline spanielcrazy

  • Site Member
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 4446
Re: here go's
« Reply #26 on: March 05, 2007, 04:10:59 PM »

Sadly, I'm not so sure that being active in the show world is an indication of reputability :( Many of the show breeders (some doing very well) that I have come across do not carry out heath screening/testing :(


Sadly, very true. Over here there are many breeders (all breeds) who have outstanding show records who breed just for winners, and breed a lot. Unfortunately it is often the unsuspecting pet owner who bears the brunt of the heartache, work and expense when the genetic defects inevitably show up.

In the past it was very difficult to try to research these things as so many people would deny that there were problems in their lines. Now with all the testing and registries available the job has become much easier, but still requires some digging.

A pedigree peppered with CH or FTCH's is a desirable thing, but a lot depends on who the champion is. If it's Ch. I Throw FN, then it's worse than useless.
The madhouse: Michelle, Joy, Jordie, Gizmo, Bracken, Jewel

"My darlings,I love you more than life itself, but you're all ****ing mad!"  Ozzy Osbourne


Offline Jane S

  • Administrator
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 13205
  • Gender: Female
Re: here go's
« Reply #27 on: March 05, 2007, 04:17:58 PM »
I'm not going to get into the debate about whether or not show or working breeders are proliforating the BRS I think it would just go round in a circle and get us no where especially as these volumes fluctuate and both are as bad as each other.  Both also have the disadvantage that pet breeders are breeding from them so its a little difficult to tell just from the pedigree who is truely working their dogs and who is a pet breeder, think the same can be said of the show world.

Sorry Tasha but you started that particular debate by stating that show breeders are producing too many dogs without any evidence at all to back that up ;) I can certainly tell from the BRS roughly how many litters are being produced by breeders who actively show since the show world is actually quite a small one where we all know everyone else (even if only by name). If you don't want this kind of debate, it's maybe best not to make generalisations that you can't substantiate ;)

Jane

Offline Michele

  • Site Member
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 8680
  • Gender: Female
Re: here go's
« Reply #28 on: March 05, 2007, 05:02:51 PM »
In my humble opinion, the BRS actually makes for quite depressing reading. It is very easy to see the small number of litters bred by true show and working folk.
The majority of the registrations are made up from indiscriminate breeding, which give themselves away not least by the colours of the pups, solid and parti-colours in the same litter, and litter's colours described as Apricot Roan, Copper, Champagne, Black with White Markings. Also bitches bred from on consecutive seasons  :'(



What I can assure is that any dog that I breed will be returned to me and I will either rehome it or retain it, restrictions will be placed on the pups with a requirement to have health checks done at my expense.  I have the facilities to keep up to ten dogs at a time and a large family who have always been happy to hold and home dogs for me if needed :D

Breeding from her is certainly not something that I am taking lightly, there will be no financial gain only a loss and I doubt that the majority of breeders have gone to the lengths that I have before considering a litter....


Very commendable Tasha, but when you get down from your pedestal you will find that you are among like minded people here on COL.
I find your superior attitude very offensive.

Offline JaspersMum

  • Donator
  • Hero Member
  • *
  • Posts: 9982
Re: here go's
« Reply #29 on: March 05, 2007, 05:35:38 PM »
One thing that I have noticed is that both dogs and bitches sometimes change hands from a "showing breeder" to a BYB and as they may have had the health screens done, it would be difficult to see on paper if the new owners are breeding responsibly or strictly for profit until the same number reappears on a number of occasions.

Whilst the health box is ticked, is this not as bad is constant use of this pairing will surely lead to the bitch being unable to produce good pups long term?

I would have expected a responsible breeder to have neutered the dogs before passing on?

Surely the KC could do more to ensure the safe continuation of the breed by owners having to be registered more stringently before a litter can be registered,and eg. only if health tests done, only 1 litter per 2 years and raise the age of the bitch from 1 to 2 or similar. 

The KC were talking about this on the Crufts preview programme but seem content just to keep registering litters. I would have expected breeders for profit would not be able to sell their pups for such high prices and buyers would have a little more security in breeders being cosha if the KC documents were then issued.

Just my thoughts  :huh:

Jenny - owned by Jasper, Ellie, Heidi, Louie & Charlie