I don't think it is a desire to protect at all costs... I think it is the fact that we are providers for them - we provide food, warmth, companionship and a sensible structure to life. Honey really isn't the most affectionate dog, but she definately needs to know we are there for her, and I know she wouldn't cope with kennels... I'm sure part of the reason she is so unsettled when we all visit my in-laws is because we've left her there before, and while she's fine once we're gone, the fear of us actually going makes us all being there more stressful than her being there on her own...

I guess that would make sense of why Normy is more affected by seperation, as she trusts you to give her the structure she needs to cope with other dogs etc, and when you're not there she's lost that security...
